Dropping a Title from Your Collection: The Internal Struggle

Dropping a Title from Your Collection: The Internal Struggle

Comic fans know that keeping up a collection can be hard work. Backing boards, bags, and even the books themselves become costly, almost to the point of “expensive” depending on how many titles are in your pull list. However, there’s one struggle every fan needs to deal with:

When the collecting becomes too much, you might need to drop a title you’ve been collecting for a very long time.

“FEED ME, KEITH! FEED ME!” Photo Credit: Public Storage

Yes, I’m talking about dropping the book that’s been there for you through thick and thin.

You two went through a lot. I’ve been through it before with Ultimate Spider-ManNew AvengersBatman and Daredevil. I am currently going through it now with Guardians of the Galaxy.

“Hey, remember what made the first run so great? Let’s ignore everything about it!” Photo Credit: Marvel Comics

I’ve collected Guardians since the relaunch in 2013. The whole Brian Michael Bendis run was great and the stories were entertaining and always left me wanting more. The artwork by Steve McNiven and Valerio Schiti was on point. However, the current run by Gerry Duggan and Aaron Kuder just isn’t clicking with me. There seems to be something missing with the new creative team; it’s like the fun isn’t there, and the artwork by Kuder doesn’t fit the book in my opinion.

You just hate breaking up the collection. It takes time and money to build a long run of a certain title and, quite frankly, complete runs are quite the accomplishment in comic collecting.

You almost feel guilty, like you’re turning your back on a friend. But, you know it’s for the best.

I tried dropping Ultimate Spider-Man for a while after I got tired of it. It was after long-time artist Mark Bailey left.

Ultimate Spider-Man in its glory days. In the wink of a young girl’s eye, glory days. GLOOOORRY DAAAAAAAAYYYYYYS! Photo Credit: Marvel

The series’ new artist, Stuart Immonen, was fine, but he didn’t have that spark with writer Brian Michael Bendis. However, as soon as I was about to drop it from my pull list, How I Met Your Mother’s certified Graduation Goggles kicked in. I just couldn’t drop the book.

I thought, “What’s an extra $2.99 a month? Ehhh, won’t hurt to keep the collection going. So what if the book isn’t all that great now?”

Then I kept reading the book, hoping it would get better. It didn’t. The book went from being about the adventures of Spider-Man to being about him and his amazing friends Ice Man and Firestar. But much like a person stuck in a bad relationship, I eventually mustered up the strength, got the confidence I needed, and dropped the book.

My “Ah ha!” moment was when I was bagging and boarding the books. I took a look at myself and realized the collection didn’t run me, I ran the collection! Nowhere is there a doctrine stating that once you start a series, you must see it through.

I know I sound like a psychopath, but you do feel guilty when you drop a series you collected for a long time. It doesn’t feel natural leaving the comic store without that one series you bought for so long. You feel like you forgot something after you left.

After not buying it for a few times, I felt good not spending money on a book I no longer enjoyed. Now, I had more money to discover better books like The Incredible Hulk during its “World War Hulk” arc or Ed Brubaker’s Captain America run.

“Why spend money on a book you don’t enjoy? That’s not economically smart.”

Well, like I said, dropping a book you collected for a long time is easier said than done. Sure, if you eventually sell the run, it’s more valuable if it is complete. People on eBay more often buy complete runs as opposed to interrupted runs. But eventually, I found that spending $2.99 on a book I didn’t enjoy was too high a price.

Now that a lot of comics push the $4 mark, I’m much more comfortable dropping a book if I don’t like it. Sure, having a big collection of a certain book feels great as a collector. However, when you lose the passion or excitement for a title but still collect it for the sake of the collection, it eventually becomes costly.

Was there ever a series you wanted to drop but just couldn’t let go? Chime in the comment section below and let me know!


  1. Amazing Spider-Man. The book has been suffering for years at this point under the hands of a writer who fundamentally misunderstands the appeal of it, and is adamant on maintaining a vice-like death grip on the book. The occasional good story doesn’t excuse the wave of mediocrity Dan Slott pushes forth.

    But I just can’t drop it from my pull list. I love Spider-Man; he’s my favorite character. I’m hoping Zdarsky’s new Spectacular Spider-Man book will help me drop Amazing for the foreseeable future.

Comments are closed.